Mate's Table
Subscribe
Create
Share with the community

What would you like to make?

Add a recommendationShare a place worth gathering around.Create a guideBuild a useful list for your city.
For business

Restaurant

City Oltra

Shop 11/1 Eddy Ave, Haymarket NSW 2000, Australia

Recommended by 25 people

Updated

Find City Oltra

Shop 11/1 Eddy Ave, Haymarket NSW 2000, Australia

Directions ↗
+61 423 808 400
HoursMonday: Closed Tuesday: 4:00 – 10:00 PM Wednesday: 4:00 – 10:00 PM Thursday: 4:00 – 10:00 PM Friday: 4:00 PM – 12:00 AM Saturday: 4:00 PM – 12:00 AM Sunday: Closed

*Opening hours may differ during holidays.

Book Now

About City Oltra

Tucked down the Eddy Avenue stairs by Central Station—neon glowing, hip-hop on the speakers—City Oltra rescues transit dining with serious dough. Diners lock onto the dual-style lineup: wide New York slices with a crisp fold alongside thick Detroit squares bordered by a crunchy frico edge. Regulars back the potato and sausage cut, though the Diavola Bianca drizzled with hot honey keeps a loyal following of its own. Counter cuts cater to quick train runs, but sitting down earns you crumbed olives, a cold negroni, and a house-made cookie ice cream sandwich.

  • Dual Crust Styles: Traditional New York-style thin crusts alongside thick, fluffy Detroit squares with crunchy cheese rims.
  • Counter Slices & Splits: Order single slices straight from the display cabinet or split whole pies half-and-half across toppings.
  • Bar Snacks & Drinks: Shareable crumbed olives, garlic bread, and sharp cocktails anchor the sit-down bar space.
  • Coeliac-Friendly Base: Dedicated coeliac-friendly focaccia square bases bake up thick, pillowy, and crisp.
RestaurantPizzaRestaurant

What's On at City Oltra

Upcoming events, special menus and other reasons to plan a visit.

No events or specials listed right now.

Why Diners Choose City Oltra

From caramelized Detroit crusts to late-night R&B tunes by Eddy Avenue, reserve your table to experience Sydney’s premier station-side pizza bar.

  • Dual-Crust Detroit and NYC Formats

    Thick, airy Detroit-style square pies with caramelized cheese frico edges stand out alongside classic New York thin-crust slices.

    The square pizza has a nice fluffy dough and the crisp cheesy edges were really yummy.

    Sophia Psaros

  • Flexible Slice & Half-and-Half Ordering

    Guests can customize their meal by splitting full square pies across toppings or grabbing individual slices on the fly.

    You can order half and half pizzas.

    JBD

  • Pumping Hip-Hop & High-Energy Beats

    A soundtrack of classic hip-hop and R&B injects an electric rhythm that keeps energy high across the room.

    the hip hop tunes that they were playing was so good I couldn’t help but bop my head.

    Erik Joshua Abella

  • Hidden Central Station Gem

    Tucked beneath Central Station, the venue transforms a transit corridor into a cozy, hip urban hideaway.

    A secret pearl hidden right under our nose in Central Station.

    Daniel Mörsdorf

  • Effortless Group Catch-Ups

    Casual tables and shareable Detroit squares create an effortless backdrop for winding down with friends.

    The vibe was really cool and welcoming, perfect for a casual hangout.

    Yogesh Devdhariya

  • Post-Work Drinks & Pizza

    A dedicated cocktail bar serving sharp house drinks makes this the ideal meeting ground right after work.

    the perfect post work cocktail and the yummiest pizza ever!

    Grace Rayner Sullivan

From crisp Detroit-style squares to craveable bar bites, explore what regulars order most—and reserve your spot to experience them fresh.

  • Potato and Sausage Pizza

    The Potato with sausage was a standout and the Salami pizza was also absolutely delicious.

    Laura L

  • Crumbed Olives

    The crumbed olives are also great.

    Bella Swan

  • Rancho Relaxo Pizza

    Their square pizzas are hands down the best we’ve had - especially the Rancho Relaxo, which is absolutely delicious.

    Bronwyn Jones

  • Diavola Bianca Pizza

    The pizzas are so delicious- in particular I love the Bianca pizza with the hot honey.

    Natasha Brown

Other favorites

Complement your slices with house desserts, savory snacks, and bar classics.

  • Cookie Ice Cream Sandwich

    Don’t forget to try their house made Ice Cream sandwiches - worth leaving a bit of tummy space for.

    Laura L

  • Garlic Bread

    The garlic bread was insane.

    Sophia Psaros

  • Fish Fingers

    Also tried the fish fingers, which were surprisingly good..

    Yogesh Devdhariya

  • Negronis

    The negronis are also fantastic and the perfect accompaniment to the pizza.

    Bronwyn Jones

Beyond the menu

Thoughtful hospitality gestures and dietary accommodations that elevate the casual slice shop experience.

  • Attentive Birthday Recognition

    When guests flag an occasion in their reservation, multiple team members make a point to personally acknowledge and celebrate the birthday throughout the meal.

  • Proactive Spice Relief

    If someone finds the chili or hot honey too intense, the floor team promptly provides a soothing side sauce to cut through the heat.

  • Coeliac-Friendly Focaccia Crust

    Diners with coeliac disease can order a dedicated gluten-free square base baked like a pillowy focaccia with crisp caramelized cheese edges.

  • Flexible Group Walk-In Care

    Even during peak Friday evening service, the floor team accommodates unexpected walk-in groups of seven without hesitation or hassle.

Frequently Asked Questions

What styles of pizza can you order?

City Oltra bakes two distinct styles: traditional thin New York-style round crusts and thick, pillowy Detroit-style square pizzas known for their crispy, caramelized cheesy edges. Whole pies can also be ordered half-and-half with different toppings.

Can you order individual pizza slices?

Yes, counter takeaway slices are available from the display cabinet for a quick bite alongside full whole pizzas.

Are gluten-free options available?

Yes, City Oltra prepares coeliac-friendly gluten-free square bases baked into a thick, pillowy focaccia style with crispy edges.

Do you need a reservation, and is walk-in seating available?

Reservations can be booked online, though walk-ins and bar seating are warmly accommodated when space permits. Keep in mind the venue has modest indoor seating and limited capacity for larger groups.

Explore more places in Sydney

Find familiar flavours, neighbourhood favourites and somewhere new in Sydney.

Similar places

More places for the flavours and food you enjoy.

Browse all Sydney venues