Restaurant
Brooklyn Boy Bagels
19 Carrington Rd, Marrickville NSW 2204, Australia
Find Brooklyn Boy Bagels
19 Carrington Rd, Marrickville NSW 2204, Australia
Directions ↗*Opening hours may differ during holidays.
Book NowAbout Brooklyn Boy Bagels
Inner West regulars treat this Marrickville warehouse as gospel for classic Brooklyn chew. The draw is the crust-to-crumb ratio—blistered outside, dense within. The move: pick an onion or za'atar round, then layer on pastrami, warm tuna melts, or a morning Benny bagel with bacon and runny egg yolks. Customers routinely walk out with an assorted half-dozen sack and a tub of scallion schmear.
- Brooklyn Boil-and-Bake: Traditional kettle-boiled rounds baked fresh across varieties like onion, za'atar, jalapeno, and everything for a genuine crust and chew.
- Hefty Deli Sandwiches: Two-handed builds packed with hot pastrami, Reuben brisket, bacon-and-egg breakfast combos, and tuna melts.
- Bulk Sacks & Tubs: Take-home sacks of assorted unfilled bagels and house schmear tubs packaged for stocking home freezers or weekend catering.
What's On at Brooklyn Boy Bagels
Upcoming events, special menus and other reasons to plan a visit.
No events or specials listed right now.
Why Brooklyn Boy Bagels Stands Out
From classic chew to loaded deli specials and take-home sacks, taste Sydney's genuine slice of Brooklyn—book your visit today.
Authentic Boil-and-Bake NYC Texture
Brooklyn Boy Bagels preserves traditional New York boiling and baking methods, producing the essential blistered, crisp crust and satisfying dense chew that purists crave.
chewy, fresh, and as close to New York-style as you’ll find in Australia
Steve Clarke Generously Stacked Deli Sandwiches
Freshly assembled made-to-order sandwiches feature generous portions of cured meats like pastrami and corned beef, accompanied by authentic sides.
one of the best Reubens I’ve had in recent times.
Harley F Bulk Takeaway for Home Feasts
Customers can buy mixed sacks and half-dozens of unsliced bagels to take home, making everyday breakfasts and weekend DIY feasts effortless.
Get a half dozen and make your own feast at home
Ally Stress-Free Event Catering
Curated bagel boxes accompanied by assorted schmears offer seamless, crowd-pleasing solutions for morning-after gatherings and catered events.
We ordered a bagel box with schmears to serve our guests the morning after our wedding, they went down a treat!
Andrew Crowe True Expat Nostalgia & Relief
Expatriates and seasoned travelers find deep satisfaction in tasting genuine Brooklyn craftsmanship after facing soft, standard bakery rolls.
am so happy I found this place and can now get a proper bagel!
Danielle Sheffler Irresistible Morning Euphoria
From the first warm, savoury bite, the unmistakable crunch and quality spark pure, spontaneous excitement that sets the tone for the day.
I still can't wipe the smile off my face
Matthew
Most popular items
Customer favourites stacked on authentic boiled-and-baked New York bagels.
Pastrami Bagel
The bagels are absolutely amazing, especially the pastrami bagel
Fotis P Bacon, Egg & Cheese Bagel
had a delicious toasted bacon egg and cheese on a plain bagel. Just the right crunch to chew ratio
Doug Anderson Lox Bagel
Really enjoyed the Lox bagel, was a good size, delicious and I was really full afterwards!
Mr G Benny Bagel
had the Benny Bagel with bacon. The bagel was light and crispy this time and the egg yolks were runny as they should be.
Brian L
Other favorites
Beyond the boiled-and-baked classics, round out your visit with specialty drinks, catering boxes, and bakery sweets.
Matcha Latte
I also enjoyed the nice strong matcha latte.
Brian L Bagel Box with Schmears
We ordered a bagel box with schmears to serve our guests the morning after our wedding, they went down a treat!
Andrew Crowe PBJ Doughnut
the PBJ doughnut (I'll be back for you again, Gorgeous !)
John O'Hare Little Marionette Coffee
They do a great job with one of the better roasts around IMHO too ... Little Marionette.
John O'Hare
Before you head over
Essential pointers on pricing, stock timing, and bulk takeaways—plan ahead and book your order before popular bakes sell out.
Factor In the Build-Your-Own Pricing
Be prepared for how sandwiches are priced: display boards list the filling price separately from the base bagel cost, with an additional small upcharge for specialty styles like jalapeño cheese, tiger, or za'atar.
Arrive Early for Peak Selection
Flavours thin out considerably as the morning progresses. Arrive early in the morning to snag the full selection of freshly boiled-and-baked bagels before top options like onion sell out.
Pre-Order Bulk Sacks and Schmear Online
If you are catering a breakfast crowd or taking home a dozen bagels with tubs of schmear, submit a large order online in advance for a fast, hassle-free pickup or delivery.
Explore more places in Sydney
Find familiar flavours, neighbourhood favourites and somewhere new in Sydney.
Similar places
More places for the flavours and food you enjoy.
- The Bagel Co.Rose Bay · Bagel, Bakery, Sandwich Shop, Cafe, Restaurant
- Pizzabox CaféKogarah · Pizza, Brunch, Coffee, Lebanese, Restaurant, Bakery, Cafe
- Shuk By The BeachBondi Beach · Israeli, Takeaway, Bakery, Cafe, Restaurant
- Wholegreen Bakery & Cafe Sydney CitySydney · Brunch, Restaurant, Bakery, Cafe, Takeaway
- OrganicaConcord · Brunch, Coffee, Cafe, Bakery, Restaurant, Beverage
- 15cenchi Japanese cheesecake The GaleriesSydney · Cake, Japanese, Cheese, Bakery
More in Marrickville
Keep exploring this neighbourhood.
- Rice Pantry - Marrickville MetroMarrickville · Chinese, Vietnamese, Restaurant
- Viet Rolls MarrickvilleMarrickville · Vietnamese, Restaurant
- Bourke Street Bakery MarrickvilleMarrickville · Coffee, Bakery, Cafe
- BarzaariMarrickville · Restaurant
- Red Rattler TheatreMarrickville · Restaurant
- TitaMarrickville · Brunch, Cafe
Discover more in Sydney
Explore another side of the city's food and drink.
- Little Lagos Bistro & BarNewtown · African, Restaurant, Bar
- Picnic Point Chinese RestaurantPicnic Point · Chinese, Restaurant
- Il Cugino Pizzeria LeichhardtLeichhardt · Pizza, Restaurant
- Air LabCabramatta · Pancake, Cake, Restaurant
- Hungry Paulie 愛呷囝仔Eastwood · Taiwanese, Restaurant
- Zeus Street Greek Surry HillsSurry Hills · Greek, Restaurant, Takeaway
