Mate's Table
Subscribe
Create
Share with the community

What would you like to make?

Add a recommendationShare a place worth gathering around.Create a guideBuild a useful list for your city.
For business

Restaurant

Ugly Pizza

32 Banksia Rd, Caringbah NSW 2229, Australia

Recommended by 0 people

Updated

Find Ugly Pizza

32 Banksia Rd, Caringbah NSW 2229, Australia

Directions ↗
+61 2 9524 5444
HoursMonday: Closed Tuesday: Closed Wednesday: 5:00 – 8:30 PM Thursday: 5:00 – 8:30 PM Friday: 4:30 – 9:30 PM Saturday: 4:30 – 9:30 PM Sunday: 12:00 – 8:30 PM

*Opening hours may differ during holidays.

Book Now

About Ugly Pizza

Caringbah locals head here for New York–style slices with zero fuss. Expect foldable thin crusts, generously dressed pies, and garlic bread built for casual crew catch-ups. Slip through the cool-room door into neighboring Huxleys for sports-bar seating, draft beer, and plates of buffalo wings alongside an Ugly Special topped with prawns, pepperoni, and chilli.

  • Connected to Huxleys Sports Bar: Pours draft beer and plates up buffalo wings next door via the cool-room door.
  • New York–Style Slices: Foldable, American-style thin crusts loaded with balanced toppings like prawns and chilli.
  • All-You-Can-Eat Nights: Weekly all-you-can-eat pizza specials draw lively groups on select nights.
RestaurantPizzaRestaurantTakeaway

What's On at Ugly Pizza

Upcoming events, special menus and other reasons to plan a visit.

No events or specials listed right now.

Why Choose Ugly Pizza

Discover why locals choose Ugly Pizza for New York crusts, sports bar crossover dining, and stress-free catering.

  • Authentic New York Style Crusts

    Ugly Pizza prepares authentic New York style bases with versatile group toppings and quick delivery turnaround.

    Love the new york style base.

    Anthony Carman

  • Generous Portions for Group Feeds

    Generously sized pizzas and shareable sides make dining or ordering at home easy and satisfying for groups.

    The pizzas were really good in quantity, taste and toppings.

    Soroush Jafari

  • Seamless Access to Huxleys Sports Bar

    Guests can dine directly inside Huxleys sports bar through the cool room door, enjoying full bar service alongside pizza orders.

    shown the hidden sports bar and resturant through the cool room door

    Brett Milsop

  • High-Value All-You-Can-Eat Social Nights

    Scheduled all-you-can-eat pizza deals create a lively and budget-friendly destination for gatherings of hungry friends and families.

    Great place for family and friends, the All you can Eat special is a great deal for those that are hungry.

    Brandon Dingle

  • Seamless Event and Party Catering

    Dedicated management support ensures large party catering orders run smoothly with reliable coordination and delicious results.

    The manager Brock was extremely helpful, making the process seamless!

    Emily Davies

  • Dependable Coordination Under Pressure

    Fast, responsive problem-solving and immediate order assistance give party planners total reassurance on busy evenings.

    all our food including the missing pizza was delivered despite them having a massive catering job on.

    Karen Kavanagh

Customer favorite pizzas on our New York style crust

  • Ugly Special Pizza

    Ugly special with prawns, pepperoni and chilli is *chef's kiss*.

    Anthony Carman

  • Mushroom and Truffle Pizza

    Personally I reckon like the mushroom and truffle pizza is the best.

    Chris

  • Peri Peri Chicken Pizza

    We ate in for dinner and ordered the Peri Peri Chicken, Triple P, Chilli Prawn, Ugly Special and kids ham and cheese. It was all delicious.

    Sarah M

  • Triple P Pizza

    We ate in for dinner and ordered the Peri Peri Chicken, Triple P, Chilli Prawn, Ugly Special and kids ham and cheese. It was all delicious.

    Sarah M

Other favorites

Delicious sides and starters to complete your meal

  • Garlic Bread

    The Pizzas and Garlic bread were absolutely delicious also, making for the perfect catering option!

    Emily Davies

  • Spinach Rolls

    They gave some complimentary spinach rolls/buns and they were amazing and everyone loved it.

    Soroush Jafari

  • Buffalo Wings

    We ate inside Huxleys and also ordered the buffalo wings.

    Sarah M

  • Dough Balls

    Large pizza was enough to share between two adults, with the dough balls and two kids pizzas all proving good value for a family of four

    A carman

Beyond the menu

Thoughtful service touches and custom accommodations experienced by guests

  • Complimentary baked extras on delivery

    Customers ordering delivery have received surprise extras like complimentary cheese-topped spinach rolls served with lemon to accompany their meals.

  • Half-and-half customization during all-you-can-eat

    During high-volume all-you-can-eat dining sessions, staff accommodate table preferences by splitting toppings half-and-half across ordered pizzas.

  • Thoughtful leftover packing for shared tables

    Dine-in guests sitting in the connected sports bar receive proactive takeaway boxes from staff to easily pack up leftover pizza slices.

  • Swift direct replacement during large catering runs

    Kitchen and management staff step in immediately to replace missing delivery items directly in under thirty minutes, even while running large catering jobs.

Before you head over

Practical tips for seating, ordering, and specials at Ugly Pizza

  • Arrive Early for Seating

    Tables are available on a walk-in basis with no reservations accepted. Arriving early, around 5:00 PM on busy nights like Fridays, helps secure seating without waiting.

  • Ordering and Shared Seating at Huxleys

    Ugly Pizza operates alongside Huxleys next door; orders can be placed from the bar area, with access to sports bar seating and wings through the cool room door.

  • Plan Around All-You-Can-Eat Nights

    Dine-in promotions feature all-you-can-eat specials on select days like Tuesdays and Sundays, with staff accommodating half-and-half topping options for sharing.

Explore more places in Sydney

Find familiar flavours, neighbourhood favourites and somewhere new in Sydney.

Browse all Sydney venues