Mate's Table
Subscribe
Create
Share with the community

What would you like to make?

Add a recommendationShare a place worth gathering around.Create a guideBuild a useful list for your city.
For business

Restaurant

Tonino's Penshurst Pizzeria

43 Penshurst St, Penshurst NSW 2222, Australia

Recommended by 80 people

Updated

Find Tonino's Penshurst Pizzeria

43 Penshurst St, Penshurst NSW 2222, Australia

Directions ↗
+61 2 9579 3610
HoursMonday: Closed Tuesday: 5:00 PM – 10:30 PM Wednesday: 5:00 PM – 10:30 PM Thursday: 5:00 PM – 10:30 PM Friday: 5:00 PM – 11:00 PM Saturday: 5:00 PM – 11:00 PM Sunday: 5:00 PM – 10:00 PM

*Opening hours may differ during holidays.

Plan your visit

About Tonino's Penshurst Pizzeria

Tonino's Penshurst Pizzeria delivers throwback neighborhood pizza loaded with fresh toppings and genuine charm. Regulars drop in for reliable, old-school classics alongside Aussie rock photos lining the walls. The kitchen turns out house-made gluten-free crusts with actual crunch and pull—matching the texture of standard dough without skipping a beat. Orders like the Mediterranean and spicy Mexicana arrive hot from the oven at prices that feel straight out of 2008.

  • Homemade Gluten-Free Base: Crusts made in-house capture the soft pull and crisp crunch of traditional dough.
  • Throwback Rock Atmosphere & Value: Photos of Australian rock music legends line the walls alongside large pies priced under $20.
RestaurantPizzaRestaurant

What's On at Tonino's Penshurst Pizzeria

Upcoming events, special menus and other reasons to plan a visit.

No events or specials listed right now.

Why Locals Choose Tonino's Penshurst Pizzeria

From homemade gluten-free crusts to nostalgic rock decor and attentive service, discover why Penshurst locals choose Tonino's.

  • Perfected Bases and Fresh Ingredients

    Every pizza is prepared with fresh toppings and crusts baked to perfection, delivering authentic flavors across classic and gourmet selections.

    Our pizza’s cooked to perfection, from the base to the toppings everything was first class.

    Adam Bowley

  • Scratch-Made Gluten-Free Dough

    Unlike venues relying on dense pre-baked crusts, Tonino's prepares homemade gluten-free dough that delivers both soft crumb and crisp edges.

    The GF pizza base was homemade and it had both the soft and crunchiness of a normal pizza base.

    Teleah M

  • Warm Neighborhood Hospitality

    From the moment patrons walk through the door, the team provides enthusiastic, dedicated, and welcoming hospitality.

    From the minute I walked in I was greeted and made to feel welcome.

    Adam Bowley

  • Energized, Attentive Service

    Diners experience attentive, fast, and proactive table care delivered by staff passionate about quality service.

    Customer service is very fast and friendly, it has been a long time since I have seen staff competitive in a Customer service setting, such a breath of fresh air!

    Noname

  • Classic Rock Decor and Nostalgic Value

    Tonino's preserves classic independent pizzeria value with large pizzas under $20 alongside walls filled with iconic Australian rock memorabilia.

    If you like australian rock music, you should come down and check out the pictures on the wall

    Noname

  • Sensory-Friendly Dining Options

    Thoughtfully paced seating windows on weekday evenings provide a calm, low-sensory dining experience for families and neurodivergent guests.

    Sensory issues: if you have a child or friend/partner on the spectrum, bring them in on a Tuesday night when it is quiet

    Noname

Before you head over

Practical advice on timing, dietary options, and ordering at Tonino's Penshurst Pizzeria

  • Time Your Visit for Quieter Hours

    For low-sensory dining or to skip rush periods, plan your visit for Tuesday evening or early at 5pm on Wednesday, Thursday, or Sunday.

  • Order the Homemade Gluten-Free Crust

    Take advantage of their house-made gluten-free pizza base on gourmet selections, which bakes with the soft and crunchy texture of traditional dough.

  • Confirm Current Menu Pricing

    Menu pricing can vary across older online listings and brochures, so check in directly or ask when ordering to confirm current item prices.

Explore more places in Sydney

Find familiar flavours, neighbourhood favourites and somewhere new in Sydney.

Discover more in Sydney

Explore another side of the city's food and drink.

Browse all Sydney venues